Download PDF

Judicial Review in India: Balancing Parliamentary Sovereignty and Constitutional Supremacy

Author : Dr. Abdul Sajid

Abstract :

Judicial review is a critical aspect of the Indian constitutional system as it safeguards the legislative and executive powers used by the authorities within the boundaries enshrined in the Constitution. Judicial review and parliamentary sovereignty versus constitutional supremacy have continued to be a significant topic of constitutional discourse ever since the declaration of Independence. In India, in contrast to the British constitutional system where traditionally the main law-making power is held by Parliament, it follows a system of constitutional supremacy where Parliament bases its powers on the Constitution. This paper is a critical discussion of the constitutional roots, historical development and judicial interpretation of parliamentary power and judicial review. The special emphasis is on the formulation of the doctrine of basic structure in terms of Shankari Prasad Singh Deo v. Union of India, I.C. Golak Nath v. State of Punjab and Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala. Significant decisions that pertain to the protection of fundamental rights, independence of the judiciary, federalism, legislative privileges and constitutional amendments are also discussed. It also takes into consideration recent developments in the Constitution, such as electoral bonds, political responsibility and constitutional authorities. The article takes the doctrinal approach to law research, meaning that the idea of judicial review and parliamentary democracy cannot be construed as antithetical ideas. Parliament should not lose significant power to serve democratic and socioeconomic goals, and the judiciary should guarantee that the power does not compromise the fundamental rights and the essential elements of the Constitution. The article finds its conclusion on the premise that constitutional supremacy with a concurring judicial review and proper judicial restraint presents the best way to uphold democratic accountability, institutional balance and rule of law in India.

Keywords :

Judicial Review, Parliamentary Sovereignty, Constitutional Supremacy, Basic Structure Doctrine, Constitutional Amendments, Separation of Powers.